Menu

A False Answer

Part of the Polynomials & Rational Expressions section of Coddy's Algebra 2 journey. Lesson 37 of 51.

Solve x+1x−1=2x−1+4\frac{x+1}{x-1} = \frac{2}{x-1}+4. Multiply both sides by x−1x-1 to get x+1=2+4(x−1)x+1 = 2+4\left(x-1\right). Expand: x+1=4x−2x+1 = 4x-2, so 3x is 3 and x is 1. Now put 1 back into the original: x−1x-1 is 0, and you cannot divide by 0. x = 1 is not a solution at all.

Where did it come from? At x = 1, multiplying by x−1x-1 meant multiplying both sides by 0, and that makes any two sides equal. So the new equation has a solution the original never had. Such an answer is called extraneous: a false answer that the working produced and the original equation refuses.

With x = 1 thrown out and nothing else left, this equation has no solution. That is a correct, finished answer, not a failure.

challenge icon

Challenge

Solve xx−4=4x−4+2\frac{x}{x-4} = \frac{4}{x-4}+2. Check every answer in the original equation.

Try it yourself

xx−4=4x−4+2\frac{x}{x-4} = \frac{4}{x-4}+2

Get xx alone

All lessons in Polynomials & Rational Expressions