Menu

A False Answer

Part of the Radicals & Rational Exponents section of Coddy's Algebra 2 journey. Lesson 24 of 40.

Squaring makes two different numbers look alike: -3 and 3 are not equal, but their squares are both 9. So squaring can turn a false equation into a true one, and the squared equation may have answers the original does not.

Take x+6=x\sqrt{x+6} = x. Squaring gives x+6=x2x+6 = {x}^{2}, so x2−x−6=0{x}^{2}-x-6 = 0, which factors as (x−3)(x+2)=0\left(x-3\right)\left(x+2\right) = 0. The candidates are 3 and -2. Check each in the original. For 3: 9\sqrt{9} is 3, and the right side is 3. True. For -2: 4\sqrt{4} is 2, but the right side is -2. False. So -2 is thrown out, and the only answer is 3.

A candidate that the working produces but the original equation rejects is a false answer (textbooks say extraneous). It is not a slip in your algebra: the squaring brought it in. That is why every candidate is checked in the original equation, never in the squared one, where both pass.

challenge icon

Challenge

Solve x+7=x−5\sqrt{x+7} = x-5. Squaring gives two candidates: check both in the original equation and keep only the one that works.

Try it yourself

x+7=x−5\sqrt{x+7} = x-5

Get xx alone

quiz iconTest yourself

This lesson includes a short quiz. Start the lesson to answer it and track your progress.

All lessons in Radicals & Rational Exponents